Princesses or Pornstars?
What’s it like being a young woman today? Feminists won the equal rights war back in the 70s, and young women today have it so much easier than their mothers, right? Wrong, argues Emily Maguire in her new book Princesses or Pornstars?
Society today is most comfortable to categorise women as Princesses (in need of protection) or Pornstars (peoples whose major duty is to be attractive and turn on men). Her new book looks at how the treatment of young women as fragile or in need of male assistance can be as objectifying and damaging to women as pornography. You may have read recently about the ‘Peek a Boo’ Pole Dancing Kit being sold as a toy for girls on the website of a major British retailer. A friend was exacerbated last week by the sexual innuendoes she witnessed being performed by local high school girls in a bid for male attention. In another new book on this controversial topic, What’s Happening To Our Girls? Maggie Hamilton explores the idea that a whole generation of females are being ‘overstimulated, over-sold, and oversexed.’ “Alongside the dazzling possibilities, subtler forces are emerging that threaten the many gains girls have made,” she says. If, like me, you find the role models for younger women today very disappointing, then this may be part of the problem. ‘Generation Skank’ as they are now referred, seem to have snuck up on us. The question is however, how can we teach young women to have confidence in their sexuality and be able to represent it in a positive way? It is a complicated issue, and not to allow teenage girls to speak openly about being sexual puts them in danger. "Some of the most dangerous situations I was in was because I felt so ashamed and so on the outer, I would never speak up about anything to do with that part of myself," Maguire says. "The best thing you can do is acknowledge that many teenagers are sexual – not necessary sexually active, or sexually knowledgeable, but that they are sexual creatures – that is what part of what they are." When asked why some young women embrace these over-exposed Hollywoord role models, Maguire says, “There can be a (temporary) self-esteem boost that comes with that kind of attention. The reassurance that they’re ‘hot’ can provide relief – again, temporary – from the anxiety that they’re not meeting fashion-magazine or pornography influenced beauty standards. Given how much pressure young women are under to conform to these beauty standards, the temporary self-esteem boost that comes with that kind of attention can be a powerful incentive.” “Rather than telling young women their behaviour is self-objectifying or some other term that blames women for doing what their culture encourages them to do, I think we need to attempt to change the way young women think about sex and sexuality. It’s hard, especially for younger people who have little experience. Sexual empowerment comes from knowing what you like, and from being able to communicate that without shame. Young women need to value their own sexual pleasure rather than trying to conform to some external idea of sexiness.” Maguire continues, “Most girls find role models in their immediate circle. So while they might copy Paris Hilton’s outfits, they’re more likely to look to their mum or aunty or teachers for guidance and inspiration. I’d say the better the real life role models, the less influence the celebrity type will have.” Hamilton supports this. “Sharing experiences learnt from your own teen experiences is helpful; ridiculing your daughter’s culture is not." Hamilton feels it is very important that parents need to resist the temptation to appear ‘cool’ by turning a blind eye to inappropriate behaviour. “What I’ve tried to do is give them back the confidence to be parents.” Local expert Rebecca Thomson works extensively in Brisbane with parents and their teenage daughters. Through individual sessions and workshops for parents and their daughters, young women and their identity are explored. Confidence, self esteem, self worth and young women’s sexuality are all delved into. Readers can contact Rebecca directly at Rebecca@elevateyou.com.au for advice on this topic or for more information about her coaching sessions and workshops.
This blog is designed for Brisbane women, about Brisbane women. Have your say here.
Who are appopriate role models for young women today? How do you feel about the sexual advertising directed at teenage girls? Do you feel that young women and their sexuality has become more complicated post feminism? I would like to hear from parents of teenage daughters and how they have handled any challenges in this area.
If you would like to suggest a topic or provide feedback on this blog then I would love to hear from you. If you would also like to be part of the Brisbane Woman blog and forum, then please email me and receive a weekly reminder.
Thank you for interest and participation.


I enjoyed this article. I could not agree more and think this is a real issue to day for young women. It is like they are growing up too fast and feel that acting in an overly sexual way moves them into womenhood faster.
I am often shocked by what I se young girls wearing. I am only in my 30′s and am shocked, I can only imagine what older ladies must feel. I was alwasy taught by my mum that a women who respects herself does not need to expose herself, expecially for male attention.
God, what hope do they have with Britney, Lyndsey and Paris to look up to? It is no wonder there is so much confusion. I think young women are misguided today be believing that sexuality is a step into womanhood, we all know it is so much more than this.
I am horrified when I go into a store and see piece bikinis as revealing as what i wear, in the kids section and I’m talking the sizes that 5 and 6 year old girls wear.
Saying that, I used to be comfortable and confident enough to show my mid drift and wear short skirts and it was not for male attention. I was 16 and older though.It was for the fact that it was summer, I take pride in my body and it was not for male attention that I dressed like that. And I was a dancer, still am, so it was more acceptable to me to wear clothes I could move and train in.
I look back at photos and I like what I used to look like and it gives me the motivation to lose the last few kilos and keep on with the exercise. I never looked skanky, Always wore things that matched, and wore appropriate underwear (never wore black bra under white shirt!) etc.
I cant wait to be able to wear these thing again, as we come into summer and I regain my confidence!
This is an extremely complex issue, every young woman (and not so young woman) wants to feel attractive. Unfortunately many teenagers equate sex with attractiveness. As Kathleen mentioned above, if the only role models teenage girls have are Britney, Lindsay and Paris then it is no wonder they are confused. However Britney, Lindsay and Paris are three young women who had similar sexually powerful celebrity role models, who then themselves felt the added pressure of Hollywood and the paparazzi to conform to the sexual stereotype that so commonly prevails.
I think it is a confusing time for young women def. Feminism has been given a bad wrap by people who don’t really understand it and I think this has affected young women’s perception of the women’s movement and has made them rebel in some cases. They don’t want to be a bra burning feminist so they go the other way. It is a shame because feminism is really just about respect and women being treated as equal.
It is a problem and with a teenage daughter I am very aware of this. I have set rules about what i deem as appropriate or not when it comes to the clothes she wears. We reach a compromise mostly but is is an on-going issue.
What is the definition of “young”? Does it mean under 18?
I find the label “generation skank” so incredibly offensive, even if I’m not part of the definition of young. What are girls so supposed to do? Maguire suggests that if they dress like Britz, but act like their mother, that’s okay. But it’s mothers (perhaps not their own) and others who are calling them skanks! That’s not exactly fair on young girls who are already probably ragingly insecure. Is it a self-fulfilling prophecy?
as a grandmother of five girls i remember my teenage years well- whohoo did i get up to such tricks!! then i saw my daughter make the same mistakes or have a good time, we fluctuate betwen the two, that is what life is about. then low and behold the grand daughters are doing the same behaviours with the same results, with each generation we seem to all go through it and survive. to lecture others on what we did ourselves seems to me to be a little misguided, i would rather discuss my mistakes in the hope that this may influence their behaviour, or at least help them to see that they are not ‘bad’- todays girls are much more informed about themselves and the world, let them explore the world just as i did without feelings of guilt or regrets and if they do have either help them through it-kids today cann’t even play by themselves there is always an adult in sight, therefor they don’t get a chance at an early age to make decisions by themselves,or to solve problems themselves, so when teenage years arrive they have to start doing it about big things like sex and relationships, when they have not made small decisions about whether to play hop scotch or tag-everything is done for them and to them. give them a go and give them credit for being intelligent they’ll work it out – we did!!
Sadly I see young girls every day at the shops, out to dinner, at clubs who are beautiful in their own right though they still feel they need to show as much flesh as possible to attract male attention. I think there is nothing more stunning than a confident female wearing a dress which shows off her femininity rather than all the flesh.
On the other hand, I feel for young girls these days (and I am only 33) there seems to be some much pressure for them to dress, act and carry on in a fashion that is beyond there years.
I have a 4 year old son and am pregnant with my second child. All I can say is that I really hope I am having another boy because I think the ‘dealing with a daughter’ issues is all too hard. I empathise with mothers of daughters these days because I too remember what happened around me when I was a young girl and would hate to have to worry about my daughter going through all that too.
I have seen this ‘generation skank’ in full action, and all I can say is there does seem to be a need for ground rules between teenagers and their parents. Kids in general unfortunately seem to not be aware that there is also sexual predators/paedophiles out there that feed off this ‘lack of concern’ towards what they wear. The other concern is the actual attitude of some of these girls, and they are rude and downright selfish, and have no respect towards their elders. It all begins at home.